The bump button was removed, but it just led to people leaving endless replies that simply said "bump" or "up" or "asdl;kjfdla;kjfda;lkj" which creates the same problem of needlessly bumping the thread but also creates the new problem of sending everybody who follows the thread a notification.
I get why the bump button was brought back, but popular threads that aren’t active very often don’t need to be bumped just to try to fish for more likes on 3 week old content. That’s spam.
Yeah, I agree, but generally forums like this run on software that has options and settings you can toggle on and off. Setting it up so only certain threads have a bump button isn't really possible. If it were up to me I'd have it so threads could only be bumped if the last activity was at least a month ago, but
1. That's also likely something beyond what the software is already configured to handle
2. That would just lead to idiots posting garbage replies anyway.
I don't think people realize how much garbage there really is. Most threads on this site have something like 5+ garbage replies that get moderated and deleted in between every post that actually gets posted. It's just a constant stream of dudes who have never contributed posting "any updates?", "she posted today", "who's going to be a king?", etc etc etc